How a council of elders reaches a decision
A common way of deciding without voting: talk until nearly everyone can accept the outcome.
Presented by ClearTrust Free for classrooms, newsrooms and the curious.
- An issue arises. Something needs settling. Two families quarrel over a field boundary, or the village must decide whether to accept a road. The matter is raised with a headman or an elder.
- Council is called. The council gathers at a customary place. In Botswana the Tswana meet at the kgotla, an open public court. Khasi villages in Meghalaya hold a dorbar, an assembly of the village.
- Everyone is heard. People speak in turn. In many councils anyone affected may talk for as long as they need. Listening fully is part of the process, not a delay before it.
- Custom is weighed. Elders set the case against custom: the unwritten rules and remembered past decisions of the community. They ask what was done before and what would be fair now.
- Consensus is sought. The aim is consensus, meaning an outcome everyone can live with, not a majority vote. The Haudenosaunee Grand Council passes a matter between groups of chiefs until they agree.
- Decision announced. When the talk settles, a senior person states the decision aloud. Saying it in public makes it binding, because the whole community has witnessed it.
- Relations repaired. The goal is to repair relations. The party at fault may pay compensation or host a meal. Many councils now debate who gets a seat, including women and the young.